change language
sei in: home - rassegna stampa newslettercontattilink

Sostieni la Comunità

20 Maggio 2011

Four titles from a bumper crop of Italian books

versione stampabile

On a per capita basis, Italy probably churns out more books on the Catholic church each year than anyplace else on earth. Given the boost created by the May 1 beatification of Pope John Paul II, this spring has been an especially busy period for the Italian market, generating several titles that will likely make their way into translations and shape Catholic conversation around the world.

This week, I’ll offer brief sketches of four such titles to emerge from the recent bumper crop.

* * *
First up is Andrea Riccardi’s Giovanni Paolo II: La Biografia (“John Paul II: The Biography”), published by Edizioni San Paolo. By now there’s a vast John Paul II literature, but this biography -- more than 600 pages long, abundantly documented, and written by someone who enjoyed insider’s access throughout the papacy -- joins the elite group of works that really matter in terms of shaping John Paul’s legacy.

Though it’s a bit facile to put things this way, one could say that just as George Weigel’s Witness to Hope has become the defining presentation of John Paul II for North Atlantic conservatives, Riccardi’s biography will likely become the key point of reference for the European center-left.
To be clear, that’s more a judgment about the likely reception of these books, not so much the intentions of their authors. Both Weigel and Riccardi are serious intellectuals, both have produced works that merit careful consideration regardless of someone’s ideological alignment, and their accounts actually converge far more often than they clash.

That said, there’s no doubt that Riccardi looks at John Paul II through a different set of glasses.

An accomplished historian, Riccardi is best known as the founder of the Community of Sant’Egidio, one of the “new movements” in the Catholic Church. It was born amid the European ferment of 1968, among young Italian progressives who wanted to change the world and yet stay Catholic. In the decades since, Sant’Egidio has become known for its ecumenical and inter-faith outreach, anti-death penalty activism, advocacy on behalf of immigrants and the poor, as well as peace-making and conflict resolution. Among its emblematic accomplishments, Sant’Egidio helped negotiate an end to Mozambique’s long-running civil war in 1992.

Riccardi devotes an early chapter to whether John Paul II was a “progressive” or a “conservative,” and concludes that neither term fits. He quotes Jan Grootaers, a well-known church historian, that in the period after the Second Vatican Council (1962-65) Karol Wojtyla was part of the “center” associated with Pope Paul VI, aligned with neither the “progressives” nor the “conservatives.”

Riccardi insists that John Paul remained fundamentally a centrist throughout his papacy.

“In Wojtyla, despite the brutal experiences of the war and of communism, there was none of the pessimism about modernity which was the usual story of Catholic thought flowing from the culture of restoration,” he writes. “His respect for democracy and his opposition to authoritarian regimes of every type are also noteworthy, as well as his insistence upon the value of conscience.”

“This was not a conservative pope,” Riccardi writes, “and much less a traditionalist.”

Riccardi nominates John Paul II as “the pope of Catholic complexity,” meaning a leader who defied all attempts to reduce Catholicism, or for that matter his own papacy, to an ideological position.

In the run-up to the beatification, the current president of Sant’Egidio, Italian layman Marco Impagliazzo, defined John Paul as “the pope of globalization,” meaning a pope who embraced the non-Western world and prepared Catholicism to make its way in a global village. It’s no surprise, therefore, that Riccardi’s chapter on John Paul as a global leader -- someone who saw past the divisions of the Cold War, and who, through his travels and his advocacy, embraced the rising cultures of the global South -- is a pivot point of the biography.

While conceding John Paul’s lifelong aversion to Marxism, Riccardi stresses the pope’s equal-and-opposite skepticism about “savage capitalism.” Through repeated calls for greater North/South solidarity, Riccardi argues, John Paul II embodied a “third position” beyond communism and capitalism, one which sought to integrate economic liberty and free markets with the value of solidarity and a strong role for public authorities.

Though some analysts took John Paul’s last social encyclical, Centesimus annus in 1991, as a sort of post-Berlin Wall endorsement of capitalism, Riccardi sees it differently.

“In reality, the pope wanted to keep his distance from capitalism, but in a world which, by then, was completely capitalist,” he writes.

Naturally, Riccardi also underlines John Paul’s commitment to peace-making, to multilateralism and empowerment of developing states, and to harmony among religions. He points especially to the 1986 summit of religious leaders in Assisi to pray for peace, which, Riccardi says, reflected John Paul’s “belief that the Catholic church has a special mission for promoting co-existence among different worlds.”

John Paul II, Riccardi says, was animated by a deep conviction that religions are protagonists of history, “sometimes with a subterranean force, other times as manifest subjects” of historical change. That influence could be spent for good or ill -- religions can be resources for peace, or agents of division. As a result, Riccardi observes, John Paul felt it was a matter of “healthy realism” to try to bring them together.

John Paul, according to Riccardi, pressed Catholicism towards a new “apostolate of peace.”

“The traditional impartiality of the popes with regard to countries at war was transformed by John Paul II into a passion for intervention in favor of peace, which sometimes seemed to go well beyond the limits of traditional prudence,” Riccardi writes.

John Paul II, according to Riccardi, saw no conflict between positioning Catholicism as an agent of dialogue and co-existence, and insisting on clarity about Catholic identity and a renewed missionary spirit in the church. Indeed, Riccardi argues, John Paul II correctly intuited that in a fragmented, disoriented post-modern world, only those actors clear about who they are would be able to chart an effective course for the future.

In an aspect of the book likely to be frustrating for American audiences, Riccardi does not spend much time on the sexual abuse crisis. He notes that John Paul may have been skeptical at the outset given his experience under communist regimes, when false charges of misconduct were often lodged against priests in order to limit their moral authority. Yet beginning in 2001, Riccardi says, John Paul began a process of reform which saw Rome take on a greater share of responsibility for disciplining abuser priests, and which has continued under Benedict XVI.

As a rule, Riccardi says, John Paul II was not much interested in routine ecclesiastical administration: “In his mode of governing, he tended more to stimulate the new and the extraordinary, rather than to control or direct the ordinary.”

In the end, Riccardi says, John Paul II will be remembered as a man who changed the world.

“He never resigned himself before history, and never gave up hope of changing it and overcoming it,” Riccardi said.

15 Gennaio 2018

'Fare Pace - la diplomazia di Sant'Egidio' è in libreria

IT | ES | DE | PT
21 Novembre 2017

''Mentre nelle nostre città europee si vive una profonda crisi, la storia si gioca nelle periferie'': Andrea Riccardi a Barcellona

IT | ES | CA
11 Novembre 2017

In libreria e in formato ebook ''La Parola di Dio ogni giorno 2018'' per comprendere e pregare con le Scritture

IT | ES | PT
22 Ottobre 2017

Memoria di San Giovanni Paolo II, il Papa artigiano di pace che ha insegnato a tanti a non aver paura

IT | ES | DE | FR
17 Ottobre 2017

Presentazione del libro ''Alla Scuola della Pace. Educare i bambini in un mondo globale''. FOTO E VIDEO

2 Ottobre 2017

E' disponibile online ''A Paz'', l'ebook che racconta come il Mozambico raggiunse la pace

tutte le news
21 Febbraio 2018
Famiglia Cristiana

I 50 anni di Sant'Egidio. L'abbraccio.

9 Febbraio 2018

Spadaro: la geopolitica di Francesco è fondata sulla misericordia

7 Febbraio 2018
Il Secolo XIX

Nessuno è troppo piccolo per aiutare

7 Febbraio 2018

“Fare pace”: la diplomazia della speranza cristiana di Sant’Egidio

4 Febbraio 2018
Corriere della Sera

Andrea Riccardi: «Quando Wojtyla mi disse: soltanto io difendo l’Italia e il Quirinale che cosa fa?»

19 Gennaio 2018

“Siamo qui, siamo vivi”: la famiglia Sarano, salvata da un sottufficiale tedesco

tutta la rassegna stampa
23 Gennaio 2018 | ROMA, ITALIA

Presentazione del libro ''Alla Scuola della Pace. Educare i bambini in un mondo globale''

7 Dicembre 2017 | GENOVA, ITALIA

Presentazione del libro ''Alla Scuola della Pace'' a Genova

23 Novembre 2017 | NAPOLI, ITALIA

Napoli: presentazione del libro ''Alla Scuola della Pace''

tutti gli Incontri di Preghiera per la Pace

Guida DOVE Mangiare, dormire, lavarsi - Roma 2016

Benedetta Ferone - Povertà a Napoli: venti anni di amicizia per strada

Povertà a Napoli: rilevazioni della Comunità di Sant’Egidio

Francesca Zuccari - Venti anni di amicizia per strada: la Comunità di Sant’Egidio e i senza dimora a Napoli

Rossella Rizzi

Un sogno per l'Africa

tutti i documenti

Il coraggio della speranza - Roma 2013
Lo spirito Assisi - Preghiera, dialogo, pace
Pacem Kawonga: "Un domani per i miei bambini"

1317 visite

1305 visite

1839 visite

1614 visite

1478 visite
tutta i media correlati